Running a small business is a constant juggling act—sales, marketing, operations, hiring, compliance… and then there’s payroll.
Payroll might seem straightforward: you pay your employees, file some taxes, and move on. But it’s more complicated than that. With deadlines, tax rules, calculations, benefits, and regulations, payroll can quickly eat up your time—and a single mistake can be costly.
That’s why small business owners often face a key decision:
Should you manage payroll in-house, or outsource to a payroll company?
In this blog post, we’ll break down both options, highlight the pros and cons, and help you figure out what’s best for your business. We'll also recommend a trusted payroll provider at the end.
What is In-House Payroll?
In-house payroll means that your business handles everything related to payroll internally.
This could be done by:
- You (the owner or manager)
- An internal HR or finance person
- A team using payroll software or even spreadsheets
You’re responsible for calculating pay, deducting taxes, submitting payments, filing reports, and maintaining compliance.
What are Payroll Companies?
Payroll companies, also known as payroll service providers, are third-party services that manage payroll for you.
They often offer a full range of payroll-related services, including:
- Calculating wages and taxes
- Direct deposit for employees
- Filing payroll taxes
- Handling W-2s and 1099s
- Managing benefits and time tracking
Examples of popular payroll companies include Gusto, SurePayroll, ADP, and Paychex.
Why is Payroll So Important?
Before we dive into the pros and cons, let’s talk about why payroll matters.
Accurate, timely payroll builds trust with your team. It’s also essential for:
- Staying compliant with tax laws
- Avoiding penalties or lawsuits
- Tracking labor costs
- Attracting and retaining employees
Get it wrong, and the consequences can be serious. That’s why choosing the right approach is critical.
In-House Payroll: Pros and Cons
✅ Pros of In-House Payroll
1. Control and Customization
You maintain full control over the process. You can tailor how payroll is done to suit your business’s unique needs.
2. Lower Ongoing Costs (Sometimes)
If your business is small and payroll is simple, managing it in-house may be cheaper—especially if you already have a finance or HR person.
3. Direct Oversight of Sensitive Data
Some businesses prefer to keep employee data internal for privacy and security reasons.
❌ Cons of In-House Payroll
1. Time-Consuming
Payroll takes time. Even with software, you’ll need to double-check calculations, handle exceptions, and stay current on tax law.
2. Risk of Errors and Penalties
Miss a tax filing or miscalculate withholdings? That can lead to fines, angry employees, and a whole lot of stress.
3. Limited Scalability
As your team grows, your payroll process becomes more complex—more hours, more rules, more room for error.
4. Requires Constant Learning
Tax codes change. Benefits evolve. You’ll need to keep learning to stay compliant.
Outsourcing to a Payroll Company: Pros and Cons
✅ Pros of Using a Payroll Company
1. Time Savings
Payroll companies handle the nitty-gritty so you can focus on your business.
2. Reduced Risk of Mistakes
Top providers have systems and experts in place to avoid costly errors.
3. Automatic Tax Filing and Compliance
No more worrying about missing tax deadlines or calculating deductions incorrectly.
4. Scales Easily with Growth
Whether you have 2 or 200 employees, payroll companies grow with you.
5. Access to Additional Features
Many services include:
- Employee portals
- Benefits management
- Time tracking
- HR support
6. Better Employee Experience
Employees love direct deposit, pay stubs they can access online, and professional support.
❌ Cons of Using a Payroll Company
1. Monthly Cost
You’ll pay a fee—usually per employee, per month. For very small teams, this might feel like an unnecessary expense.
2. Less Custom Control
You may be limited by the provider’s system in how you manage certain processes.
3. Reliance on a Third Party
If there’s an outage or support delay, you’re at the mercy of their timeline.
4. Data Security Concerns
Your employees’ information is stored externally, so choose a provider with strong security protocols.
Cost Comparison: In-House vs. Payroll Provider
| Factor | In-House Payroll | Payroll Company |
|---|---|---|
| Software/Tools | $0 - $100/month | Usually included in service |
| Labor/Time | 5–20+ hours/month | Minimal—minutes per pay period |
| Tax Filing | Manual or semi-automated | Typically automatic |
| Compliance Risk | Medium to high | Low |
| Penalties (if errors) | Common if not careful | Rare with reputable provider |
| Total Estimated Cost | Varies (hidden time costs can add up) | ~$35–$100/month for small teams |
When Should You Use In-House Payroll?
In-house might be right for you if:
- You have fewer than 5 employees
- You or someone on your team has experience with payroll
- Your payroll is very simple and predictable
- You want full control over the process
- You’re on a tight budget and willing to invest time instead of money
When Should You Use a Payroll Company?
Outsourcing might be the better choice if:
- You’re growing or plan to grow
- You have multiple pay schedules, freelancers, or benefits
- You’re struggling to keep up with compliance
- You want to save time and reduce stress
- You’re looking for an all-in-one HR and payroll solution
A Real-World Scenario: Meet Lisa
Lisa runs a small bakery with 8 employees. At first, she used a spreadsheet and manually calculated payroll every two weeks. It took her 6–8 hours per month. Then she forgot to file a quarterly tax form and got hit with a $400 IRS penalty.
She switched to a payroll company, and now it takes her less than 30 minutes a month. Her employees love getting pay stubs and W-2s online. Lisa? She loves not dealing with tax deadlines.
Moral of the story: Payroll outsourcing can be a game-changer.
What to Look for in a Payroll Company?
If you decide to outsource, don’t just pick the first name that pops up.
Look for a provider that offers:
- Transparent pricing (no hidden fees)
- Automatic tax filing
- Direct deposit
- Employee access to pay stubs/W-2s
- Support for contractors and freelancers
- Time tracking integration
- Benefit management
- Responsive customer service
- Secure data handling
Why We Recommend Gusto?
If you’re looking for a trusted, all-in-one payroll solution, Gusto is a standout choice—especially for small businesses.
Here’s why we recommend it:
⭐ User-Friendly Interface
Even if you’re not tech-savvy, Gusto’s platform is clean, simple, and easy to use.
⭐ All-in-One Payroll + HR
Gusto handles payroll, taxes, benefits, PTO tracking, onboarding, and more—no need for multiple systems.
⭐ Affordable Plans
Pricing starts low, with transparent fees that scale with your business.
⭐ Automated Compliance
Gusto automatically calculates and files federal, state, and local payroll taxes—saving you hours.
⭐ Great for Remote Teams
If your employees work in different states, Gusto supports multi-state payroll with ease.
⭐ Employees Love It
Team members can log in, see their pay stubs, W-2s, and update personal info without bothering you.
Final Thoughts: What's Right for You?
There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Here’s a quick breakdown to help guide your decision:
| Choose In-House If... | Choose a Payroll Company If... |
|---|---|
| You have <5 employees and simple payroll | You’re growing or have complexity (benefits, contractors) |
| You want complete control | You want to save time and reduce error risk |
| You or your team understand tax and compliance rules | You’re tired of dealing with forms and deadlines |
| You have a very tight budget | You want automation and peace of mind |
Ready to Make Payroll Easy? Try Gusto
If you’re leaning toward outsourcing, Gusto is a top-rated payroll provider trusted by thousands of small businesses. It’s easy to set up, packed with useful features, and surprisingly affordable.
👉 Check out Gusto today and give your team (and yourself) the payroll experience you deserve.
Need More Help Deciding?
Feel free to reach out or drop your questions in the comments. Payroll is one of those things that’s easy to ignore—until it becomes a problem. Don’t let it. Choose the right path now, and your future self will thank you.
Disclosure: Some of the links in this article are affiliate links. This means that if you click on a link and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. These commissions help support our blog and allow us to continue providing helpful content. We only recommend products and services we trust and believe will add value to our readers.
